Each year in mid-SepÂtemÂber, we celÂeÂbrate Banned Books Week, and each year I see a handÂful of peoÂple arguÂing that the celÂeÂbraÂtion, or memoÂrÂiÂal, is self indulÂgent and out of touch. No one in the U.S. seriÂousÂly tries to ban books, right? Book banÂning — as Gayle King said last SepÂtemÂber on CBS MornÂings — is “an issue we tend to assoÂciate with the past.”
Yet even before the recent moral panÂics over “critÂiÂcal race theÂoÂry” and genÂder and sexÂuÂalÂiÂty issues, teachÂers and librarÂiÂans would have strongÂly disÂagreed that attempts to ban books ever went away. Books are chalÂlenged all the time in front of school boards, and have, many times in the recent past, appeared on lists handÂed around by state and fedÂerÂal legÂisÂlaÂtors.
The latÂest round of book banÂnings repÂreÂsents an escaÂlaÂtion, rather than a return, of the tacÂtic. Not that lawÂmakÂers are likeÂly to have read any of 850 or so books on a recent list of susÂpects. But too many seem eager to endorse bills that restrict what stuÂdents can read, teachÂers can teach, and libraries can lend — legÂisÂlaÂtion soleÂly based on the stanÂdard of “comÂfort.” As in… if the facts of AmerÂiÂcan hisÂtoÂry make some stuÂdents (or their parÂents) uncomÂfortÂable, then damn the facts of AmerÂiÂcan hisÂtoÂry.….
Ta-Nahasi Coates — whose Between the World and Me was banned in some comÂmuÂniÂties in 2020 — tells King that this is no coinÂciÂdence. “For most of AmerÂiÂcan hisÂtoÂry,” he says, “African AmerÂiÂcan authors have not had the purÂchase on the AmerÂiÂcan conÂscience that they do right now.” The same goes for LGBTQ authors and writÂers from othÂer marÂginÂalÂized groups, whose books are chalÂlenged and banned in schools and libraries with aggresÂsive freÂquenÂcy.
What Coates calls a “purÂchase on the AmerÂiÂcan conÂscience” is what we might also call empaÂthy — a qualÂiÂty that good writÂing inspires in curiÂous readÂers, and that many peoÂple seem to find threatÂenÂing. Every democÂraÂcy, howÂevÂer, must learn that it is “ignoÂrance [that] is danÂgerÂous,” as presÂiÂdent of the New York PubÂlic Library Tony Marx writes, “breadÂing hate and diviÂsion.” LearnÂing about, and carÂing about, the expeÂriÂences of othÂers does the oppoÂsite.
To keep banned books freely availÂable to readÂers who want access to them, the New York PubÂlic Library has partÂnered with pubÂlishÂers in a project called Books for All to reach readÂers wherÂevÂer they may be. Marx emphatÂiÂcalÂly states the need for such an effort:
The recent instances of both attemptÂed and sucÂcessÂful book banÂning — priÂmarÂiÂly on titles that explore race, LGBTQ+ issues, reliÂgion, and hisÂtoÂry — are extremeÂly disÂturbÂing and amount to an all-out attack on the very founÂdaÂtion of our democÂraÂcy.… The Library’s role is to make sure no perÂspecÂtive, no idea, no idenÂtiÂty is erased.
There are curÂrentÂly four books offered under the proÂjecÂt’s aegis through the end of May, and they’re availÂable to readÂers across the UnitÂed States:
Speak | LauÂrie Halse AnderÂson (Square Fish / MacmilÂlan PubÂlishÂers)
King and the DragÂonÂflies | Kacen CalÂlenÂder (ScholasÂtic)
Stamped: Racism, Antiracism, and You | Jason Reynolds and Ibram X. KenÂdi (LitÂtle, Brown Books for Young ReadÂers / Hachette Book Group)
The CatchÂer in the Rye | J.D. Salinger (LitÂtle, Brown and ComÂpaÂny / Hachette Book Group)
To access these titles, all of which have faced bans or chalÂlenges, you will need to downÂload the NYPL’s free readÂer app, SimÂplyE, for iOS or Android–all from the Books for All site. Then you can read the book right away “with our withÂout a library card,” the library notes. “No waits, no fines.”
One hopes the Books for All project will expand to offer more titles from the increasÂingÂly greater numÂber of books being pushed out of pubÂlic view because they make those in powÂer uncomÂfortÂable. Or, betÂter yet, one hopes that dozens of simÂiÂlar projects will arise; that the sloÂgan “books for all” can become a realÂiÂty, regardÂless of who makes polÂiÂcy. Learn more and sign up for your free SimÂplyE account at the Books for All site.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
America’s First Banned Book: DisÂcovÂer the 1637 Book That Mocked the PuriÂtans
Read 14 Great Banned & CenÂsored NovÂels Free Online: For Banned Books Week 2014
Josh Jones is a writer and musiÂcian based in Durham, NC. FolÂlow him at @jdmagness
What a great resource and helpÂful artiÂcle! Thanks for sharÂing.