It cerÂtainÂly may not feel like things are getÂting betÂter behind the anxÂious veils of our COVID lockÂdowns. But some might say that optiÂmism and pesÂsimism are prodÂucts of the gut, hidÂden someÂwhere in the bacÂteÂrÂiÂal stew we call the microÂbioÂme. “All prejÂuÂdices come from the intestines,” proÂclaimed notÂed sufÂferÂer of indiÂgesÂtion, Friedrich NietÂzsche. Maybe we can change our views by changÂing our diet. But it’s a litÂtle hardÂer to change our emoÂtions with facts. We turn up our noses at them, or find them imposÂsiÂble to digest.
NietÂzsche did not conÂsidÂer himÂself a pesÂsimist. Despite his stomÂach trouÂbles, he “adoptÂed a phiÂlosÂoÂphy that said yes to life,” notes ReaÂson and MeanÂing, “fulÂly cogÂnizant of the fact that life is mostÂly misÂerÂable, evil, ugly, and absurd.” Let’s grant that this is so. A great many of us, I think, are inclined to believe it. We are ideÂal conÂsumers for dystopiÂan NietÂzsche-esque fanÂtasies about superÂmen and “last men.” Still, it’s worth askÂing: is life always and equalÂly misÂerÂable, evil, ugly, and absurd? Is the idea of human progress no more than a modÂern deluÂsion?
PhysiÂcian, staÂtisÂtiÂcian, and oneÂtime sword swalÂlowÂer Hans Rosling spent sevÂerÂal years tryÂing to show othÂerÂwise in teleÂviÂsion docÂuÂmenÂtaries for the BBC, TED Talks, and the posthuÂmous book FactÂfulÂness: Ten ReaÂsons We’re Wrong About the World—and Why Things Are BetÂter Than You Think, co-writÂten with his son and daughÂter-in-law, a staÂtisÂtiÂcian and designÂer, respecÂtiveÂly. Rosling, who passed away in 2017, also worked with his two co-authors on softÂware used to aniÂmate staÂtisÂtics, and in his pubÂlic talks and book, he attemptÂed to bring data to life in ways that engage gut feelÂings.
Take the set of graphs above, aka, “16 Bad Things DecreasÂing,” from FactÂfulÂness. (View a largÂer scan of the pages here.) Yes, you may look at a set of monoÂchroÂmatÂic trend lines and yawn. But if you attend to the details, you’ll can see that each arrow plumÂmetÂing downÂward repÂreÂsents some proÂfound ill, manÂmade or othÂerÂwise, that has killed or maimed milÂlions. These range from legal slavery—down from 194 counÂtries in 1800 to 3 in 2017—to smallÂpox: down from 148 counÂtries with casÂes in 1850 to 0 in 1979. (PerÂhaps our curÂrent globÂal epiÂdemÂic will warÂrant its own triÂumphant graph in a revised ediÂtion some decades in the future.) Is this not progress?
What about the steadiÂly falling rates of world hunger, child morÂtalÂiÂty, HIV infecÂtions, numÂbers of nuclear warÂheads, deaths from disÂasÂter, and ozone depleÂtion? Hard to argue with the numÂbers, though as always, we should conÂsidÂer the source. (NearÂly all these staÂtisÂtics come from Rosling’s own comÂpaÂny, GapÂminÂder.) In the video above, Dr. Rosling explains to a TED audiÂence how he designed a course on globÂal health in his native SweÂden. In order to make sure the mateÂrÂiÂal meaÂsured up to his accomÂplished stuÂdents’ abilÂiÂties, he first gave them a quesÂtionÂnaire to test their knowlÂedge.
Rosling found, he jokes, “that Swedish top stuÂdents know staÂtisÂtiÂcalÂly sigÂnifÂiÂcantÂly less about the world than a chimÂpanzee,” who would have scored highÂer by chance. The probÂlem “was not ignoÂrance, it was preÂconÂceived ideas,” which are worse. Bad ideas are driÂven by many ‑isms, but also by what Rosling calls in the book an “overÂdraÂmatÂic” worldÂview. Humans are nerÂvous by nature. “Our tenÂdenÂcy to misÂinÂterÂpret facts is instinctive—an evoÂluÂtionÂary adapÂtaÂtion to help us make quick deciÂsions to avoid danÂger,” writes Katie Law in a review of FactÂfulÂness.
“While we still need these instincts, they can also trip us up.” MagÂniÂfied by globÂal, colÂlecÂtive anxÂiÂeties, weaponized by canÂny mass media, the tenÂdenÂcy to pesÂsimism becomes realÂiÂty, but it’s one that is not supÂportÂed by the data. This kind of arguÂment has become kind of a cotÂtage indusÂtry; each preÂsenÂtaÂtion must be evalÂuÂatÂed on its own merÂits. PreÂsumÂably enlightÂened optiÂmism can be just as overÂsimÂpliÂfied a view as the darkÂest pesÂsimism. But Rosling insistÂed he wasn’t an optiÂmist. He was just being “factÂful.” We probÂaÂbly shouldn’t get into what NietÂzsche might say to that.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
PosÂiÂtive PsyÂcholÂoÂgy: A Free Course from HarÂvard UniÂverÂsiÂty
Josh Jones is a writer and musiÂcian based in Durham, NC. FolÂlow him at @jdmagness
To simÂply be ” factÂful” the artiÂcle should also include16 bad things increasÂing.
Some staÂtisÂtics are also misÂleadÂing. Just allow me me pick one examÂple: hunger, the share of peoÂple underÂnourÂished. The book shows this to be 28% in 1970 and only 11% in 2015. It would seem that underÂnourÂishÂment has more than halve. A declinÂing trend if you look at the perÂcentÂages.
Now add world popÂuÂlaÂtion data into the mix: 3,7 Bln in 1970 and 7,3 Bln in 2015. Based on the perÂcentÂages, this amounts to 1,036 Bln underÂnourÂished peoÂple n 1970 comÂpared to 803 Mln in 2015.
This would mean a much difÂferÂent graph. The data is no longer halved, but declines by 20%. Etc etc.