“Most daeÂmoÂniÂaÂcal of all shocks is that of the abysmalÂly unexÂpectÂed and grotesqueÂly unbeÂlievÂable,” goes a typÂiÂcal line in the work of H.P. LoveÂcraft. “NothÂing I had before underÂgone could comÂpare in terÂror with what I now saw; with the bizarre marÂvels that sight implied.” As a writer of what he called “weird ficÂtion,” LoveÂcraft speÂcialÂized in the narÂraÂtor plunged into a loss for words by the sheer incomÂpreÂhenÂsiÂbilÂiÂty of that which he sees before him. But in the case of this parÂticÂuÂlar senÂtence, the narÂraÂtor sees not an ancient monÂster awakÂened from its milÂlenÂnia of slumÂber but “nothÂing less than the solÂid ground” — or as the readÂer put it, nothÂing more than the solÂid ground. But then, most of us haven’t lived our entire lives locked up high in a casÂtle.
The stoÂry is “The OutÂsider,” someÂthing of an outÂlier in the LoveÂcraft canon due to its outÂsized popÂuÂlarÂiÂty as well as its GothÂic tinge. By the author’s own admisÂsion, it owes a debt to his litÂerÂary idol Edgar Allan Poe, and indeed repÂreÂsents LoveÂcraft’s “litÂerÂal though unconÂscious imiÂtaÂtion of Poe at its very height.”
In 1926 or today, one could do much worse for a modÂel than Poe, and critÂics have also detectÂed in “The OutÂsider” the posÂsiÂble influÂence of Nathaniel Hawthorne, Mary ShelÂley, and Oscar Wilde. AnyÂone darÂing to read the stoÂry aloud must thus strike a balÂance between sevÂerÂal difÂferÂent comÂpetÂing tones, and few could hope to outÂdo RodÂdy McDowalÂl’s perÂforÂmance on the 1966 record above. But as DanÂgerÂous Minds’ Paul GalÂlagher notes, that actor, “child star of Lassie Come Home and My Friend FlicÂka,” is “hardÂly a name one would assoÂciate with the masÂter of the unnameÂable.”
Though McDowall would latÂer “star in some jolÂly decent horÂror movies like The LegÂend of Hell House and Fright Night, he was in 1966 best known for the likes of “That Darn Cat! or Lord Love a Duck or the stage musiÂcal Camelot.” In the event, McDowÂell proved “almost a perÂfect choice to give life to Lovecraft’s words,” delivÂerÂing a “light boyÂish charm” comÂbined with an intoÂnaÂtion that “causÂes a growÂing disÂquiÂet and a dreadÂful sense of unease,” altoÂgethÂer suitÂable for the work of “the weird and recluÂsive LoveÂcraft.” He also brings to the role the kind of faint, unexÂpectÂedÂly refined menÂace that would make him famous as CorÂnelius and CaeÂsar in the PlanÂet of the Apes films. After “The OutÂsider” McDowall reads LoveÂcaft’s earÂliÂer stoÂry “The Hound,” and sureÂly his voice is just the one in which LoveÂcraft fans would want to hear spoÂken, for the very first time in LoveÂcraft’s oeuÂvre, the name of the NecroÂnomÂiÂcon.
Be sure to explore out colÂlecÂtion, 1,000 Free Audio Books: DownÂload Great Books for Free.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
H.P. Lovecraft’s ClasÂsic HorÂror StoÂries Free Online: DownÂload Audio Books, eBooks & More
An AniÂmatÂed IntroÂducÂtion to H.P. LoveÂcraft and How He InventÂed a New GothÂic HorÂror
MakÂing The PlanÂet of the Apes: RodÂdy McDowall’s Home Movies and a 1966 MakeÂup Test
Based in Seoul, ColÂin MarÂshall writes and broadÂcasts on cities, lanÂguage, and culÂture. His projects include the book The StateÂless City: a Walk through 21st-CenÂtuÂry Los AngeÂles and the video series The City in CinÂeÂma. FolÂlow him on TwitÂter at @colinmarshall or on FaceÂbook.
His is the perÂfect soft yet dark as the most sweetÂly bitÂter chocoÂlate for the beauÂty Eldritch telling…