AnyÂone livÂing in the West today sureÂly feels they’ve heard quite enough about its decline. (Unless, of course, they’re fans of 1980s punk rock.) GivÂen how long civÂiÂlizaÂtions usuÂalÂly outÂlive indiÂvidÂuÂals, how can an indiÂvidÂual grasp the prospects for longeviÂty of the civÂiÂlizaÂtion in which they find themÂselves? HisÂtoÂry, a disÂciÂpline which has long had everyÂthing to do with chartÂing the rise and fall of setÂtleÂments, culÂtures, and empires, can proÂvide the conÂtext necÂesÂsary for underÂstandÂing, but more of it has been writÂten than even a human with the lifesÂpan of a civÂiÂlizaÂtion can digest. Come to proÂvide some clarÂiÂty is Luke Kemp of CamÂbridge’s CenÂtre for the Study of ExisÂtenÂtial Risk, creÂator of the infoÂgraphÂic above. View it here in a largÂer forÂmat, courÂtesy of the BBC.
“There is no strict defÂiÂnÂiÂtion of civilÂiÂsaÂtion,” Kemp admits, “nor an overÂarÂchÂing dataÂbase of their births and deaths.” This forced him to come up with his own defÂiÂnÂiÂtion for this infoÂgraphÂic: “as a sociÂety with agriÂculÂture, mulÂtiÂple cities, milÂiÂtary domÂiÂnance in its geoÂgraphÂiÂcal region and a conÂtinÂuÂous politÂiÂcal strucÂture. GivÂen this defÂiÂnÂiÂtion, all empires are civilÂiÂsaÂtions, but not all civilÂiÂsaÂtions are empires.”
What comes at the end of virÂtuÂalÂly all of them, he calls a colÂlapse: “a rapid and endurÂing loss of popÂuÂlaÂtion, idenÂtiÂty and socio-ecoÂnomÂic comÂplexÂiÂty. PubÂlic serÂvices crumÂble and disÂorÂder ensues as govÂernÂment losÂes conÂtrol of its monopÂoly on vioÂlence.”
When civÂiÂlizaÂtions have colÂlapsed, as they’ve done with fair freÂquenÂcy over the past five milÂlenÂnia, “some recovÂered or transÂformed, such as the ChiÂnese and EgyptÂian. OthÂer colÂlapsÂes were perÂmaÂnent, as was the case of EastÂer Island. SomeÂtimes the cities at the epiÂcenÂtre of colÂlapse are revived, as was the case with Rome. In othÂer casÂes, such as the Mayan ruins, they are left abanÂdoned as a mauÂsoleum for future tourists.” The Roman Empire, “the vicÂtim of many ills includÂing overÂexÂpanÂsion, cliÂmatÂic change, enviÂronÂmenÂtal degraÂdaÂtion and poor leadÂerÂship” before its sackÂing by the VisigÂoths in the year 410 and the VanÂdals in 455, has come up espeÂcialÂly often in curÂrent disÂcusÂsions about the fate of the AmerÂiÂca-led WestÂern — or even globÂal — order.
The Roman Empire, as we can see on KemÂp’s infoÂgraphÂic, lastÂed 525 years: much longer than the AkkaÂdiÂan Empire, which lastÂed 187 years, but less than half as long as the African AksumÂite Empire, which lastÂed 1100. “We may be more techÂnoÂlogÂiÂcalÂly advanced now,” Kemp writes,” but this gives litÂtle ground to believe that we are immune to the threats that undid our ancesÂtors. Our newÂfound techÂnoÂlogÂiÂcal abilÂiÂties even bring new, unpreceÂdentÂed chalÂlenges to the mix. ” Kemp names among the posÂsiÂble facÂtors in the next big colÂlapse cliÂmate change, enviÂronÂmenÂtal degraÂdaÂtion, inequalÂiÂty and oliÂgarchy, as well as plain ranÂdomÂness and bad luck. GivÂen the inevitabilÂiÂty of colÂlapse, perÂhaps we can only hope that our civÂiÂlizaÂtion is ultiÂmateÂly sucÂceedÂed by a supeÂriÂor one. But then, Kemp adds, ” “We will only march into colÂlapse if we advance blindÂly. We are only doomed if we are unwillÂing to lisÂten to the past.”
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
In 1704, Isaac NewÂton PreÂdicts the World Will End in 2060
The WestÂern TraÂdiÂtion by Eugen Weber: 52 Video LecÂtures
StewÂart Brand’s List of 76 Books for RebuildÂing CivÂiÂlizaÂtion
The HisÂtoÂry of CivÂiÂlizaÂtion Mapped in 13 MinÂutes: 5000 BC to 2014 AD
Based in Seoul, ColÂin MarÂshall writes and broadÂcasts on cities, lanÂguage, and culÂture. His projects include the book The StateÂless City: a Walk through 21st-CenÂtuÂry Los AngeÂles and the video series The City in CinÂeÂma. FolÂlow him on TwitÂter at @colinmarshall or on FaceÂbook.
re: »>The Roman Empire, “the vicÂtim of many ills includÂing overÂexÂpanÂsion, cliÂmatÂic change, enviÂronÂmenÂtal degraÂdaÂtion and poor leadÂerÂship”«<
EveryÂone has his own analyÂsis into why the Roman empire colÂlapsed, and all are accuÂrate to some degree. So withÂout debatÂing Mr. MarÂshalÂl’s list, I add that the Roman empire failed because Rome’s cenÂtralÂized govÂernÂment colÂlapsed in a swamp of corÂrupÂtion, bribery and inepÂtiÂtude. By 455 AD (Mr. MarhsalÂl’s mileÂpost), the empire’s govÂernÂment in Rome had come to be feared by what was left of the plebs, and the tax colÂlecÂtor most of all was to be avoidÂed at all costs. As for the enorÂmousÂly wealthy Roman landownÂers, govÂernÂment was to be ignored at all costs, until anothÂer round of debt-forÂgiveÂness was inauÂguÂratÂed or until the local repÂreÂsenÂtaÂtive could be bribed away.
The comÂmon folk, the poor and landÂless turned to the nobles for proÂtecÂtion, and the nobles proÂtectÂed from plebs from the tax colÂlecÂtor and the milÂiÂtary recruiters. That set the stage for the feuÂdal sysÂtem that defined Europe for the next milÂlenÂniÂum.
I couldÂn’t find a verÂsion that idenÂtiÂfied all of the civÂiÂlizaÂtions on the chart. I expectÂed one of them to have a rollover ID feaÂture, but apparÂentÂly not. Very interÂestÂing but a litÂtle disÂapÂpointÂing to see labels only for a select few.
DenÂnis, the linked BBC artiÂcle has a link in the image capÂtion:
“Here’s the full list of the civilÂiÂsaÂtions disÂplayed above.”
http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20190218-the-lifespans-of-ancient-civilisations-compared
You have packed into this diaÂtribe which can be furÂther eluÂciÂdatÂed in AsiÂmov’s Guide to the Bible, way too much!
Also, most of this (regardÂing govÂernÂment) can be parsed with the text, ParaÂbles as SubÂverÂsive Speech…
ProÂfoundÂly, the thread runÂning through AsiÂmov’s work is that man has been conÂquerÂing man (one anothÂer) for over eight thouÂsand years; I want to find the cause for this paraÂdox with di-synÂchroÂnous time causalÂiÂty.
GerÂmaÂnia: The BatÂtle Against Rome — DocÂuÂmenÂtary
It is in the nature of subÂnuÂclear affects (conÂstituents) which are eterÂnal as we know from a big bang hypothÂeÂsis, the stanÂdard modÂel of what is known about physÂiÂcal immiÂnent realÂiÂty and our episÂteÂmoÂlogÂiÂcal probÂlem of perÂcepÂtion, that conÂsciousÂness and the unconÂscious are the perÂpetÂuÂal diaÂlogue by which the conÂstrast between the macroÂscopÂic and microÂscopÂic mainÂtain disÂtinctÂly, this difÂferÂent time valence of the uniÂverse as space, everyÂthing withÂin and surÂroundÂing space; this valence between matÂter and non-matÂter is di-synÂchroÂnous time…
NetÂworks and PowÂer from the FreemaÂsons to FaceÂbook
This IncredÂiÂble 4K Video of the Sun Took NASA 300 Hours to Make
FreemaÂsonÂry
SECRET ORGANIZATION
EncyÂcloÂpeÂdia BriÂtanÂniÂca
[paintiressÂes not the NowÂness]
|.>|<.|
(5:55 Di-synÂchroÂnous spin & tack)
QuanÂtum MechanÂics: Schrödinger’s disÂcovÂery of the shape of atoms
The proÂtein foldÂing probÂlem: a major conunÂdrum of sciÂence: Ken Dill at TEDxSÂBU
The UniÂverse of Minds ROMAN V. YAMPOLSKIY
Silent Weapons For QuiÂet Wars DocÂuÂment — Full Read
Where are the greatÂest and the longest CivÂiÂlizaÂtions of India and ChiÂna? It is as if they nevÂer existÂed or if they did, they nevÂer matÂtered to the EngÂlish speakÂing world. The west is known for its Hubris! But please draw two very long lines below the graph and name one the ChiÂnese and the othÂer IndiÂan, for nameÂsake!