One of the sad facts of human psychology is that knowledge can be used for evil just as easily as it can be used for good. If the human race had never figured out how to use fire, for example, we wouldn’t have to worry about those pesky arsonists.
If some people are willing to use the fruits of knowledge to hurt people, should we stop acquiring knowledge? It sounds absurd, but that’s a question that is often asked, though it’s invariably couched in different language.
When Richard Dawkins, the evolutionary biologist and outspoken atheist, made an appearance on The Daily Show last week to promote his new memoir, host Jon Stewart asked: “Do you believe that the end of our civilization will be through religious strife or scientific advancement?” The answer, Dawkins said, is probably both. “Science provides, in the form of technology, weapons which hitherto have been available only to reasonably responsible governments,” said Dawkins, and those weapons “are likely to become available to nutcases who believe that their god requires them to wreak havoc and destruction.”
The conversation then moves beyond religious fanaticism. “Science is the most powerful way to do whatever it is you want to do,” said Dawkins, “and if you want to do good, it’s the most powerful way of doing good. If you want to do evil, it’s the most powerful way to do something evil.”
Dawkins’s last statement echoes the words of Albert Einstein, who warned that the scientific method is only a means to an end, and that the welfare of humanity depends ultimately on shared goals. You can hear Einstein make his point by visiting our post, “Listen as Albert Einstein Reads ‘The Common Language of Science’ (1941)”.
Related Content:
Jon Stewart’s William & Mary Commencement Address: The Entire World is an Elective
Richard Dawkins Explains Why There Was Never a First Human Being
Anyway of seeing it if I’m in the UK?
So far many people have died because of science used by non-religious governments.
People die because of ignorance and the misuse of science or religion. nn“The most savage controversies are those about matters as to which nthere is no good evidence either way. Persecution is used in theology, nnot in arithmetic, because in arithmetic there is knowledge, but in ntheology there is only opinion. So whenever you find yourself getting nangry about a difference of opinion, be on your guard; you will probablyn find, on examination, that your belief is going beyond what the nevidence warrants.“nnQuote from An Outline of Intellectual Rubbish, by Bertrand Russell
People die because of ignorance and a misuse of science and religion.nn“The most savage controversies are those about matters as to which there is no good evidence either way. Persecution is used in theology, not in arithmetic, because in arithmetic there is knowledge, but in theology there is only opinion. So whenever you find yourself getting angry about a difference of opinion, be on your guard; you will probably find, on examination, that your belief is going beyond what the evidence warrants.“nn(quote from An Outline of Intellectual Rubbish, by Bertrand Russell)
Being a mere Australian, I am not permitted to view the video: The Daily Show is beyond my legal reach — why, I have never understood (meaning that it’s not only some American content but also a lot of British I may not view). But I want to say only that Jon Stewart is a refreshing reminder that there ARE some intelligent people sitting behind anchor desks in television. Astounding!
I would never suggest that a fellow resident of Australia abuse the rights and privileges of “the viacom entertainment family” by using the browser extensions available at https://mediahint.com/
Thank all the gods, Martin! — how appalling it would be if anyone took notice of so piratical a suggestion!nFor myself, I can’t offer you my thanks, as I have, of course, completely ignored your post, the contents of which were hitherto unknown to me and will remain so FOREVER.nHad I not done so, I would fall to the ground and kiss your toes in gratitude u2026
The “unintended consequence” would be more likely the less science is funded by government and the more science is funded by unregulated private corporations. As we have seen over the last three decades, greed does not take a back seat to public safety. And profit motives do not fund pure science they fund whatever is going to be profitable for the tiny minority of majority stock holders. Science is ever increasingly about money, period, while all of the laws are written to relive corporations and their CEOs of any responsibility or accountability for the damage they cause. Religion has played a major role in granting corporations this kind of power. Negligence, in the name of “unintended consequences” are most likely to wipe us out so long as Religion services Big Business like a prostitute.
Religion is historical science
Science in the hands of capitalists is very different than science in the hands of a democracy (one with a democratic economy of which there are no nations like this at present). Otherwise this is like saying that cars kill people, when in fact it depends on who is driving them.
But attending to this type of generalized blame or credit (to religion or to science) is actually futile — a waste of time. If each of us looked at our own self and realized that happiness only comes from there — our own self’s being in good, kind relationship. With others, with our own self, with all the universe. If this was done, how much evil could happen using science or using religion or whatsoever were used? if every one knew and focused their daily lives on that fundamental necessity to work on making good relationship? (And this is contagious; this effort can make a world culture.) Evil and good are each accomplished one by one, by each person making each decision. That does often result in collective evil or collective good — but the accomplishment occurs in the decisions of each individual who participated. And the decisions fundamentally are results of the individual’s own wisdom or ignorance about what is best for oneself, what will give oneself comfort and ease and happiness, whether it be in science’s this life, or religion’s this and next. And the key is known- attend to doing this: “Walk in beauty with all your relations” (to paraphrase the White Buffalo Calf Woman’s accurate secret of happiness and success, which is also core to the findings of most current psychological and socialogical and medical scientific research, and also the core value of most religions’ prime teachings.