If you read Open CulÂture, you probÂaÂbly love watchÂing movies. I’d wager, howÂevÂer, that you don’t love watchÂing action movies. I don’t mean that you operÂate at an intelÂlecÂtuÂal levÂel far above any such palÂtry enterÂtainÂments; I mean that the craft of action filmÂmakÂing has itself declined. You’ve sureÂly felt that today’s big-budÂget specÂtaÂcles of chase, fight, and exploÂsion — TransÂformÂers, the Jason Bourne films, last few Bonds, the latÂest BatÂman trilÂoÂgy — don’t thrill you as did those of decades past — Hard Boiled, Raiders of the Lost Ark, The Wild Bunch, Die Hard — but perÂhaps you can’t pin down quite why. Have action movies changed, you may wonÂder, or have I? GerÂman-born, UCLA-based film scholÂar Matthias Stork argues for the forÂmer, breakÂing down the corÂrupÂtion of modÂern action filmÂmakÂing in his video essay Chaos CinÂeÂma. “ThroughÂout the first cenÂtuÂry of moviemakÂing, the default style of comÂmerÂcial cinÂeÂma was clasÂsiÂcal,” he begins. “It was meticÂuÂlous and patient. In theÂoÂry, at least, every comÂpoÂsiÂtion and camÂera move had a meanÂing, a purÂpose, and movies did not cut withÂout good reaÂson.”
No longer. Where action filmÂmakÂers once “pridÂed themÂselves on keepÂing the viewÂer well-oriÂentÂed” in time and space, they now throw disÂparate images togethÂer hapÂhazÂardÂly, enslaved to “rapid editÂing, close framÂings, bipoÂlar lens lengths, and promisÂcuÂous camÂera moveÂment,” tradÂing “visuÂal intelÂliÂgiÂbilÂiÂty for senÂsoÂry overÂload,” leavÂing it to the soundÂtrack to proÂvide a semÂblance of conÂtiÂnuÂity. Stork examÂines the qualÂiÂties and effects of this new style of “chaos cinÂeÂma” in three parts. The first covÂers the visuÂal disÂinÂteÂgraÂtion of action sequences themÂselves; the secÂond covÂers the defiÂcienÂcy’s penÂeÂtraÂtion even into scenes of diaÂlogue and music and the emerÂgence of the “shaky-cam”; the third sumÂmaÂrizes and engages responsÂes to the first two parts. Whether or not mainÂstream comÂmerÂcial filmÂmakÂing will ever cure itself and return to conÂvincÂing, coherÂent action rather than the impresÂsionÂisÂtic “genÂerÂal idea of action,” we now have a fasÂciÂnatÂing diagÂnoÂsis of the disÂease. (For furÂther disÂcusÂsion of Chaos CinÂeÂma, conÂsidÂer lisÂtenÂing to Stork’s appearÂance on BatÂtleÂship PreÂtenÂsion, a favorite film podÂcast of mine.)
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
The Dark Knight: AnatoÂmy of a Flawed Action Scene
Alfred Hitchcock’s SevÂen-Minute EditÂing MasÂter Class
The 10 HidÂden Cuts in Rope (1948), Alfred Hitchcock’s Famous “One-Shot” FeaÂture Film
ColÂin MarÂshall hosts and proÂduces NoteÂbook on Cities and CulÂture and writes essays on cities, Asia, film, litÂerÂaÂture, and aesÂthetÂics. He’s at work on a book about Los AngeÂles, A Los AngeÂles Primer. FolÂlow him on TwitÂter at @colinmarshall or on his brand new FaceÂbook page.