Art, as we underÂstand the term, is an activÂiÂty unique to homo sapiÂens and perÂhaps some of our earÂly hominid cousins. This much we know. But the matÂter of when earÂly humans began makÂing art is less cerÂtain. Until recentÂly, it was thought that the earÂliÂest preÂhisÂtoric art datÂed back some 40,000 years, to cave drawÂings found in IndoneÂsia and Spain. Not coinÂciÂdenÂtalÂly, this is also when archaeÂolÂoÂgists believed earÂly humans masÂtered symÂbolÂic thought. New finds, howÂevÂer, have shiftÂed this date back conÂsidÂerÂably. “Recent disÂcovÂerÂies around southÂern Africa indiÂcate that by 64,000 years ago at the very least,” Ruth SchusÂter writes at Haaretz, “peoÂple had develÂoped a keen sense of abstracÂtion.”
Then came the “hashÂtag” in 2018, a drawÂing in ochre on a tiny flake of stone that archaeÂolÂoÂgists believe “may be the world’s oldÂest examÂple of the ubiqÂuiÂtous cross-hatched patÂtern drawn on a silÂcrete flake in the BlomÂbos Cave in South Africa,” writes KrysÂtal D’Costa at SciÂenÂtifÂic AmerÂiÂcan, with the disÂclaimer that the drawing’s creÂators “did not attribute the same meanÂing or sigÂnifÂiÂcance to [hashÂtags] that we do.” The tiny artiÂfact, thought to be around 73,000 years old, may have in fact been part of a much largÂer patÂtern that bore no resemÂblance to anyÂthing hashÂtag-like, which is only a conÂveÂnient, if misÂleadÂing, way of namÂing it.
The artiÂfact was recovÂered from BlomÂbos Cave in South Africa, a site that “has been underÂgoÂing excaÂvaÂtion since 1991 with deposits that range from the MidÂdle Stone Age (about 100,000 to 72,000 years ago) to the LatÂer Stone Age (about 42,000 years ago to 2,000 years BCE).” These findÂings have been sigÂnifÂiÂcant, showÂing a culÂture that used heat to shape stones into tools and, just as artists in caves like LasÂcaux did, used ochre, a natÂuÂralÂly occurÂring pigÂment, to draw on stone. They made engravÂings by etchÂing lines directÂly into pieces of ochre. ArchaeÂolÂoÂgists also found in the MidÂdle Stone Age deposits “a toolkÂit designed to creÂate a pigÂmentÂed comÂpound that could be stored in abalone shells,” D’Costa notes.
Nicholas St. Fleur describes the tiny “hashÂtag” in more detail at The New York Times as “a small flake, meaÂsurÂing only about the size of two thumbÂnails, that appeared to have been drawn on. The markÂings conÂsistÂed of six straight, almost parÂalÂlel lines that were crossed diagÂoÂnalÂly by three slightÂly curved lines.” Its disÂcovÂerÂer, Dr. Luca PolÂlaroÂlo of the UniÂverÂsiÂty of the WitÂwaÂterÂsrand in JohanÂnesÂburg, expressÂes his astonÂishÂment at findÂing it. “I think I saw more than ten thouÂsand artiÂfacts in my life up to now,” he says, “and I nevÂer saw red lines on a flake. I could not believe what I had in my hands.”
The eviÂdence points to a very earÂly form of abstract symÂbolÂism, researchers believe, and simÂiÂlar patÂterns have been found elseÂwhere in the cave in latÂer artiÂfacts. ProÂfesÂsor Francesco d’Errico of the French NationÂal CenÂter for SciÂenÂtifÂic Research tells SchusÂter, “this is what one would expect in traÂdiÂtionÂal sociÂety where symÂbols are reproÂduced…. This reproÂducÂtion in difÂferÂent conÂtexts sugÂgests symÂbolÂism, someÂthing in their minds, not just dooÂdling.”
As for whether the drawÂing is “art”… well, we might as well try and resolve the quesÂtion of what qualÂiÂfies as art in our own time. “Look at some of Picasso’s abstracts,” says ChristoÂpher HenÂshilwood, an archaeÂolÂoÂgist from the UniÂverÂsiÂty of Bergen and the lead author of a study on the tiny artiÂfact pubÂlished in Nature in 2018. “Is that art? Who’s going to tell you it’s art or not?”
Researchers at least agree the markÂings were delibÂerÂateÂly made with some kind of impleÂment to form a patÂtern. But “we don’t know that it’s art at all,” says HenÂshilwood. “We know that it’s a symÂbol,” made for some purÂpose, and that it preÂdates the preÂviÂous earÂliÂest known cave art by some 30,000 years. That in itself shows “behavÂioralÂly modÂern” human activÂiÂties, such as expressÂing abstract thought in mateÂrÂiÂal form, emergÂing even closÂer to the evoÂluÂtionÂary appearÂance of modÂern humans on the scene.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
Hear a PreÂhisÂtoric Conch Shell MusiÂcal InstruÂment Played for the First Time in 18,000 Years
A RecentÂly-DisÂcovÂered 44,000-Year-Old Cave PaintÂing Tells the OldÂest Known StoÂry
40,000-Year-Old SymÂbols Found in Caves WorldÂwide May Be the EarÂliÂest WritÂten LanÂguage
Was a 32,000-Year-Old Cave PaintÂing the EarÂliÂest Form of CinÂeÂma?
Josh Jones is a writer and musiÂcian based in Durham, NC. FolÂlow him at @jdmagness