GivÂen how many acaÂdÂeÂmÂic phiÂlosÂoÂphy departÂments have banÂished ExisÂtenÂtialÂism into some primÂiÂtive wilderÂness, it seems strikÂing to hear peoÂple talk about it as a curÂrent pheÂnomÂeÂnon with a seriÂous, livÂing pediÂgree and a hip youth vanÂguard disÂtillÂing its ideas into pop culÂture. By the time I’d heard of Albert Camus—by way of The Cure’s earÂly sinÂgle “Killing an Arab”—the refÂerÂences to the French philosoÂpher and his novÂel The Stranger were already exotÂic, and as kitschy as the faux-MidÂdle EastÂern guiÂtar line in the song. But in 1959, the hipÂster exisÂtenÂtialÂist was a pheÂnomÂeÂnon so wideÂspread that NorÂman MailÂer wrote a scathing essay about the charÂacÂter.
And a CanaÂdiÂan jourÂnalÂist, sitÂting down to interÂview ExisÂtenÂtialÂist philosoÂpher Simone de BeauÂvoir, began by askÂing her to comÂment on the “group of noisy, rowÂdy jazz-lovÂing young peoÂple, in the immeÂdiÂate post-war periÂod.” This first wave of 50s Parisian hipÂsters embraced Sartre, Camus, and BeauÂvoir right along with Coltrane and CharÂlie ParkÂer.
BeauÂvoir disÂmissÂes any conÂnecÂtion between her kind of ExisÂtenÂtialÂism and that of the rowÂdy massÂes except that of physÂiÂcal proxÂimÂiÂty. NonetheÂless, like 90s femÂiÂnist punk rockÂers who spread the ideas of third wave femÂiÂnism, the French and AmerÂiÂcan Beats made ExisÂtenÂtialÂist phiÂlosÂoÂphy cool.
BeauÂvoir prefers to draw a clear boundÂary between her work and the next generation’s approÂpriÂaÂtion. By this time, both Sartre and Camus had disÂavowed the term ExisÂtenÂtialÂist and had a falling-out over ComÂmuÂnism. But BeauÂvoir uses the term and refers to a “We,” who “think—and it’s one of the most imporÂtant points in existentialism—that man is the purÂpose of man, his own future, and the purÂpose of all his activÂiÂties.” She draws on stark binaÂry oppoÂsiÂtions of “good” and “evil” to explain the “funÂdaÂmenÂtal basis of what you could call our ethics,” and yet, she says, “we don’t ask metaÂphysÂiÂcal quesÂtions.”
If it sounds like BeauÂvoir is sumÂmaÂrizÂing Sartre, that’s part of what’s going on. The interÂviewÂer keeps pressÂing to underÂstand the “exisÂtenÂtialÂist man’s conÂcepÂtion of the world.” She obligÂes, disÂcussing “SartreÂan ExisÂtenÂtialÂism” and his major work Being and NothÂingÂness and enterÂtainÂing vague quesÂtions about atheÂism and polÂiÂtics. FinalÂly, around 12:15, they begin to talk about the book for which de BeauÂvoir is best known, The SecÂond Sex, which would go on to inspire 60s femÂiÂnists like BetÂty Friedan, GloÂria Steinem, and UK colÂlecÂtivist magÂaÂzine Spare Rib.
Calm and meaÂsured throughÂout the conÂverÂsaÂtion, BeauÂvoir defends her ideas, includÂing the most provocaÂtive, that, as the interÂviewÂer paraÂphrasÂes, “You don’t believe in the exisÂtence of a femÂiÂnine nature. You believe peoÂple are first human, before being male or female.” She makes it clear right away that her anti-genÂder essenÂtialÂism has roots in an even more funÂdaÂmenÂtal, and very ExisÂtenÂtialÂist, skepÂtiÂcism: “I don’t believe in the exisÂtence of a human nature.” All of us, whatÂevÂer genÂder we’re taught to idenÂtiÂfy with, become prodÂucts of our “place, time, civilÂiÂsaÂtion, and techÂnique etc.” through culÂturÂal conÂdiÂtionÂing, not inner necesÂsiÂty.
The SecÂond Sex, she says, is not a revolt or a protest, but a descripÂtion of an oppresÂsive set of relaÂtions that “curÂrentÂly neiÂther men nor women can just transÂform… with a magÂic wand.” NevÂerÂtheÂless, de BeauÂvoir became increasÂingÂly activist as she aged, givÂing the eloÂquent interÂview on “Why I’m a FemÂiÂnist” in 1975. And above all, the younger genÂerÂaÂtion who picked up pieceÂmeal Sartre also picked up enough of Beauvoir’s work to begin forcÂing changes in the mateÂrÂiÂal conÂdiÂtions she idenÂtiÂfied as creÂatÂing genÂder-based forms of social oppresÂsion.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
Simone de BeauÂvoir Tells Studs Terkel How She Became an IntelÂlecÂtuÂal and FemÂiÂnist (1960)
DownÂload All 239 Issues of LandÂmark UK FemÂiÂnist MagÂaÂzine Spare Rib Free Online
11 EssenÂtial FemÂiÂnist Books: A New ReadÂing List by The New York PubÂlic Library
Josh Jones is a writer and musiÂcian based in Durham, NC. FolÂlow him at @jdmagness
DisÂcusÂsion needs conÂcrete examÂples.