Here is a rare recordÂing of Albert EinÂstein readÂing his speech on the immeÂdiÂate afterÂmath of World War II, “The War is Won, But the Peace is Not”:
The speech was delivÂered on DecemÂber 10, 1945, at the Fifth Nobel AnniverÂsary DinÂner at the Hotel Astor in New York. Only four months earÂliÂer, the UnitÂed States had dropped atomÂic bombs on civilÂian popÂuÂlaÂtions in the JapanÂese cities of HiroshiÂma and NagasaÂki. EinÂstein didÂn’t work on the atomÂic bomb, but in 1939 he had signed a letÂter to PresÂiÂdent Franklin D. RooÂsevelt urgÂing him to proÂcure uraÂniÂum and accelÂerÂate nuclear research. In his speech, EinÂstein draws a comÂparÂiÂson between conÂtemÂpoÂrary physiÂcists and the founder of the Nobel Prize, who inventÂed dynaÂmite.
PhysiÂcists find themÂselves in a posiÂtion not unlike that of Alfred Nobel himÂself. Alfred Nobel inventÂed the most powÂerÂful exploÂsive ever known up to his time, a means of destrucÂtion par excelÂlence. In order to atone for this, in order to relieve his human conÂscience, he instiÂtutÂed his awards for the proÂmoÂtion of peace and for achieveÂments of peace. Today, the physiÂcists who parÂticÂiÂpatÂed in forgÂing the most forÂmiÂdaÂble and danÂgerÂous weapon of all times are harassed by an equal feelÂing of responÂsiÂbilÂiÂty, not to say guilt. And we canÂnot desist from warnÂing, and warnÂing again, we canÂnot and should not slackÂen in our efforts to make the nations of the world, and espeÂcialÂly their govÂernÂments, aware of the unspeakÂable disÂasÂter they are cerÂtain to proÂvoke unless they change their attiÂtude toward each othÂer and toward the task of shapÂing the future.
But EinÂstein says he is trouÂbled by what he sees in the months folÂlowÂing World War II.
The war is won, but the peace is not. The great powÂers, unitÂed in fightÂing, are now dividÂed over the peace setÂtleÂments. The world was promised freeÂdom from fear, but in fact fear has increased tremenÂdousÂly since the terÂmiÂnaÂtion of the war. The world was promised freeÂdom from want, but large parts of the world are faced with starÂvaÂtion while othÂers are livÂing in abunÂdance. The nations were promised libÂerÂaÂtion and jusÂtice. But we have witÂnessed, and are witÂnessÂing even now, the sad specÂtaÂcle of “libÂerÂatÂing” armies firÂing into popÂuÂlaÂtions who want their indeÂpenÂdence and social equalÂiÂty, and supÂportÂing in those counÂtries, by force of arms, such parÂties and perÂsonÂalÂiÂties as appear to be most suitÂed to serve vestÂed interÂests. TerÂriÂtoÂrÂiÂal quesÂtions and arguÂments of powÂer, obsoÂlete though they are, still preÂvail over the essenÂtial demands of comÂmon welÂfare and jusÂtice.
EinÂstein then goes on to talk about a speÂcifÂic case: the plight of his own peoÂple, the EuroÂpean Jews.
While in Europe terÂriÂtoÂries are being disÂtribÂuted withÂout any qualms about the wishÂes of the peoÂple conÂcerned, the remainÂders of EuroÂpean JewÂry, one-fifth of its preÂwar popÂuÂlaÂtion, are again denied access to their haven in PalesÂtine and left to hunger and cold and perÂsistÂing hosÂtilÂiÂty. There is no counÂtry, even today, that would be willÂing or able to offer them a place where they could live in peace and secuÂriÂty. And the fact that many of them are still kept in the degradÂing conÂdiÂtions of conÂcenÂtraÂtion camps by the Allies gives sufÂfiÂcient eviÂdence of the shameÂfulÂness and hopeÂlessÂness of the sitÂuÂaÂtion.
EinÂstein conÂcludes by callÂing for “a radÂiÂcal change in our whole attiÂtude, in the entire politÂiÂcal conÂcept.” WithÂout doing so, he says, “human civÂiÂlizaÂtion will be doomed.”
Note: The full text of “The War is Won, But the Peace is Not” is availÂable in the EinÂstein antholoÂgies Out of My LatÂer Years and Ideas and OpinÂions.